# Student Sandbox v1 Trial Review Template

Use this after one student-adjacent 20-minute trial. This is a process review, not a student evaluation or grade.

## Session metadata

- Date:
- Observer role: parent / teacher / researcher / self-review
- Topic area, not raw private prompt:
- Student level: high_school / other
- Artifact reviewed:
- Consent / stop-anytime reminder given: yes / no

## Privacy check

- Student name recorded? no
- School name recorded? no
- Email / account / family detail recorded? no
- Raw private prompt saved? no
- Redaction needed? yes / no
- Redaction notes:

## 20-minute loop completion

| Phase | Completed? | Evidence / note |
|---|---|---|
| Intent in student's words | yes / no / unclear | |
| AI first pass as learning plan | yes / no / unclear | |
| Human boundary selected | yes / no / unclear | |
| Source check attempted | yes / no / unclear | |
| AI second pass changed behavior | yes / no / unclear | |
| Reflection completed | yes / no / unclear | |

## Student understanding

What did the student understand?

- AI helped with:
- Student verified:
- Student boundary:
- Student kept responsibility for:
- Student's next learning move:

## Theory track evidence

- Human capability delta:
- Source discernment:
- Reflection quality:
- Trust calibration:
- Independence preservation:
- What changed in the agent's second pass?
- What changed in the human-AI relationship?
- What should be remembered, challenged, decayed, or forgotten?

## Confusion and friction

What confused the student?

- Prompt wording:
- Source checklist:
- Boundary choice:
- Reflection card:
- Timing / cognitive load:

## Parent / teacher / observer notes

- Was AI acting like a tutor instead of a ghostwriter?
- Could the student explain the question without AI?
- Did the student preserve their own judgment before drafting?
- Was any safety/privacy instruction unclear?

## Outcome classification

Choose one:

- usable_as_is
- useful_but_confusing
- too_much_scaffold
- too_little_scaffold
- privacy_language_unclear
- source_check_too_hard
- not_ready_for_student_use

## Next-run change

Next-run change:

- Keep:
- Change:
- Remove:
- Add:

## Research note

Safe one-paragraph summary, with no identifying student data:

> 

## Linkage

- Plan: `docs/plans/2026-05-16-student-sandbox-research-study-v1-plan.md`
- Trial guide: `docs/student-sandbox-v1-trial-guide.md`
- Local scaffold: `examples/student_sandbox_v1.py`